When Arsene Wenger witnessed the rise of Spain and Barcelona he saw a sea-change. In his mind, and on the pitch, small, technically gifted, mobile players were playing 4-3-2-1 and passing and moving their way to domination of the sport. But what worked for the Iberians has never panned out in North London, and the Barca Lite tag was never meant as a compliment.

But if ever there was a game to signal a potential change in the way of doing things, it was last night’s demolition in Munich. Bayern are brilliant technically, and spend most matches dominating possession, but what stood out against Barcelona was the energy and discipline without the ball and the speed of ruthlessness with which they broke when they had it.

Just like watching the old Arsenal

There were strong overtones of the best Alex Ferguson teams, but there was also plenty of golden-era Wenger to their display. At their best under the Frenchman, Arsenal outmuscled every opponent, stifled any space they had to attack, sprung with electric speed when the opponent had over-committed and were clinical in finishing their chances.

Players like Emmanuel Petit, Edu and the divine Paddy Vieira himself epitomised the marriage of toughness and technique in midfield, while Marc Overmars, Freddie Ljungberg and Robert Pires brought as much goal threat as they did tricky creativity – much more in the case of the Swede. Up front, Dennis Bergkamp and Thierry Henry were strong and nasty as well as capable of jaw dropping feats of skill.

The future is German

For years many have been crying out for Wenger to sacrifice the possession-for-possession’s-sake style and revert to the size and skill of his best teams, and maybe, just maybe, Bayern’s monumental display will show him that playing that way – so long as the players are right – can make a mockery of Tiki Taka.

There’s reason for optimism. The boss has spoken of the shift in the youth game from Spain to Germany, and his targeting of German players in the transfer market indicates a change in his preferences.

It’s a shame to see him lose out on Lewis Holtby and Mario Goetze, but don’t be surprised to see at least one arrival from Germany this summer. Wenger’s hit-to-miss ratio in the transfer market may not be what it once was, but he can still pick a very good player, and he can improve his chances by moving away from the smaller, attacking-midfield type players that big clubs are focussing on. Julian Draxler is one of the latter, but Lars Bender could well be a wiser acquisition.

Adding steel and purpose

Switching back to a more physical style would hardly mark Wenger out as a maverick, and one performance by an outrageously talented team doesn’t mean that the Iberian way is old hat, but the current approach has shown few signs of genuine success and waiting any longer to change tack makes very little sense.

I’m not advocating abandoning the kind of play that brings the best out in Santi Cazorla and Jack Wilshere, merely adding steel and purpose to it, and I doubt there are many who would lament the arrival of someone like Bender, Marouane Fellaini or Jeremy Toulalan. Not if it helped bring back the days when Arsenal could hope, like Bayern last night, to impose themselves on the best teams around.

Latest:

Follow Arsenal Latest on TwitterRSS FeedFollow Arsenal Latest on facebookSubscribe by email



Follow Arsenal Latest on TwitterRSS FeedArsenal Latest news on FacebookSubscribe by email

Comments  

#7 thomas 2013-04-27 18:20
people seem to think just because Barca got a roasting by a great Bayern team that we witnessed the end of tiki taka football, this i very much doubt as its been a winning formula for Barca & the Spanish National team for a few years now & i expect they will bounce back & start thrashing sides with their own brand of the game fairly soon?!!
+1 #6 Mark 2013-04-27 16:04
1) Wenger has never said the youth game has shifted from Spain to Germany. He said that it's shifting from France to Spain AND Germany.
2) Julian Draxler is not small, he's 6ft 2.
3) This whole article is written on the basis of one game.
4) vilanova's treatment clearly affected the barca players.
+1 #5 Kofi 2013-04-25 08:44
Now look at Real Madrid. Expensive and and Direct. Dortmund creative and concentration on team work like Arsenal. The biggest problem at Arsenal is confidence.(Press, Fans, FA, Agents). If england understands that there is the need to have academy developed as Wenger propose 10 yrs ago as opposed to buying this would be England playing good football without leg breaking tackles.
#4 Matt 2013-04-25 00:23
I agree in the majority, it's about getting the blend of physicality and flair. In the past we've had players like Henry and Vieira who combined it perfectly and reaped the rewards. Lars Bender would be a great acquisition to the side. The tactics need to be able to go from tiki taka to direct. Giroud can only get better and there's promising stuff from the youth that our strikers will be alright + Jovetic if it happens.

What makes Bayern so dangerous is their timing. They haven't just done this over 1 season. All of German football had an overhaul and are showing signs of success. Formation wise it's a case of 4-2-3-1 which some would argue we play already, some say it's 4-3-3, 4-2-1-3. It comes down to coaching the formation and players knowing how to play it. None of the English teams deploy effective formations in big European games with united being the occasional exception.

I've always coached to the equation of;
Tactical discipline and understanding + (fast and efficient transitions + pride in accurate finishing) = success.
#3 Barnaby 2013-04-24 17:57
I'd argue that Arsene's currently attempting to set Arsenal up like a German side. We've never played with the 1-2 in midfield that Barca use, it's generally been a 2-1, similar to Bayern. The main issue is balance, and that we struggle to attack with the same speed and efficiency as Bayern do. So, this should trigger less a rethink and more of a renewed desire to get Arsenal to something like this level. There's also nothing wrong with having smaller players, they can often be the toughest (look at Wilshere). What is an issue is making sure they can cope with increased 'attention'.
-1 #2 kemjika 2013-04-24 13:20
Barcelona under the Dutchman Frank Rijkaard had a more balanced team. The insurance of a tiki taka brand of football is having big players also that could match physical teams when it becomes necessary while maintaining your style of play. Rijkaard's team to me was all round. The current Barcelona team, apart from lacking good defenders is bereft of big players. Remember the likes of Yaya Toure, Marques, Puyol, Big strikers in the likes of Eto'o, Ronaldinho and Ibra. Vilanova needs to balance his team, if he will make any meaningful success in the years ahead.
Trying to have an all Spanish football club at the expense of common sense, is not feasible. Currently,out of a 37 man team only 8 are foreign players. That cannot work. He is paying the price. Notwithstanding, the Tiki Taka brand still remains the best brand of football.
+5 #1 Kofi 2013-04-24 10:04
I think your analysis are a bit below par. Arsenal played tiki taka and beat Bayern. Arsenal is the only English team to beat Barca in open play with same tiki taka. Arsenal lost to Bayern by playing traditional direct English play.This season has shown that the so called direct English play is going no where. Manu, ManCity. Teams that did well Arsenal did not do English.